Soundtrack Central The best classic game music and more

    Pages: 1

XISMZERO Feb 11, 2008

After seeing this video on YouTube (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6JVp9kmjbzI) of Masato Honda's Assemble a Crew Live concert, I had to go out and buy the DVD to acquire premium audio for my portable listening pleasure.

Now, they don't offer this live selection on a normal audio CD so assuming my PC's DVD drive is region-free, I'm looking to explore audio ripping options (just looking to make WAVs) rather than hunting for an external region-free DVD and doing it the ol' fashioned way of recording off of home stereo equipment like I've done for some game rips in the past.

Question: What is a recommended DVD audio ripping tool I ought to explore?

Ashley Winchester Feb 11, 2008 (edited Feb 11, 2008)

There's a easy way of doing this, though I've noticed a small decrease in audio quality from doing it this way (basically it's the really cheap way of doing it cause I had everything on hand):

You'll need a program that can record audio and you'll need a cable with the male end at both ends; if you have a splitter for such a cable that also comes in real handy.

Simply plug one end into where you jack your speakers in (this is were the splitter comes in handy so you can rig the speakers in as well so you can actually hear what you're recording) and plug the other end into the mircophone port (this consitites the "in-line").

Once that's done start recording with the program you have chosen and then start the DVD or video clip.

The only catches are:
- small decrease in audio quality though a better sound card may make up for that (it may just be my crappy speakers making me think that)
- it's a good idea to put the "in-line" volume as low as it can go because you'll probably be using the volumes on the computer and whatever the video is playing in.
- beacuse of the above you'll have to tinker with the volumes
- you can't do anything on your computer that would make a noise while recording becuase you're recording live - instant messengers are the main threat.

Anyway, that's one way to do it. Though I wouldn't mind knowing about a better way to do it myself.

XISMZERO Feb 11, 2008

Ashley Winchester wrote:

There's a easy way of doing this...

Yeah that's the method I used to record audio in game rips. To tell you the truth, I've been able to obtain above average quality by using the primitive method of using line-in recording. It's what I'll likely use if I find my DVD player can't read Region 2.

Datschge Feb 11, 2008

You can extract the native audio using a tool called DVD Decrypter (discontinued, but still easy to find).

brandonk Feb 12, 2008

Great vid!!

Masato Honda's stuff is so much more over the top than where T-Square went (which is sadly, mostly a snooze fest these days, their last great album was 'Friendship' IMHO).  Great musicians. 

I've used DVD Audio Extractor on several occassions: http://www.castudio.org/dvdaudioextractor/

However, take note, when using that app, extract' to .wav, then use EAC and Lame to rencode to VBR Mp3.  Something about the built in MP3 encoder that tripped out my iPod when playing them (the tracks would cut short on my iPod, but not when I played them in winamp...odd). 

I have not tried DVD Decrypter for audio extraction (never thought to), however to get the files off of the DVD natively, in mp3, that would best...not sure if that format is immediately compatible with MP3 players or how the 'rip' process works on DVD Decrypter...will have to check that out.


- Brandon

Datschge Feb 12, 2008

Actually with video DVDs the audio is most likely in AC3 (Dolby Digital) format, so you'd need to recode it anyway.

jb Feb 12, 2008

DVD Audio Extractor.  Don't waste your time with that line out to line in recording crap, if you're ripping anything that is of decent sound quality you're going to lose too much.

Put in the DVD, choose the audio chapters, convert it to WAV (don't forget to downsample from 48k to 44.1) and encode in whatever app/codec you use to rip regular music cds.

    Pages: 1

Board footer

Forums powered by FluxBB