So, Super 8. I certainly enjoyed it, but I have to agree with the reviews: the movie often feels like two different genres desperately competing for the attention of the viewer. AICN's Nordling says it best:
"It's been written in various articles that Abrams originally came up with the coming-of-age story first, and then attached the monster movie to it. There's a lot of places in the movie that do feel like an abrupt shift in tone, having characters behave differently than they've been established previously in the film. And although the monster portion of SUPER 8 lacks focus, it still works, because all these events are shot from the perspective of the kids, and it becomes a grand adventure. It does feel like Abrams needed to take a couple more drafts to iron out exactly what he wanted the alien to be - is it a monster, or is it misunderstood? It's never exactly clear. Abrams wanted to do something different than E.T. or ALIEN, so he made the creature a mix of both and that makes the alien's story not make a lot of logical sense in the light of day. But the creature design is impressive, and the movie knows how to deliver the jolts and action. Abrams has always been effective at that."
That tonal shift is apparent not just because the alien plot is half-baked, but also because by contrast, the coming-of-age narrative is handled so well. The kids are the heart and soul here, and they capture ragtag likeability perfectly. Their 'film within a film' could easily carry the entire movie, and there's just a genuine sense of fun watching their home project come together. Then we come to the alien part. On the one hand, Abrams does a great job keeping the creature under wraps for the better half of the movie. The trailer's famous train wreck sequence is a phenomenal highlight, and seeing it in its entirety is almost worth the price of admission alone. The jolts and scares are effective, even unnerving, creeping into outright sci-fi horror at times. (The experience is enhanced by the stellar sound mix. I haven't been this impressed with a film's sound effects since Abrams' own Star Trek.) But on the other hand, the eventual reveal of the beast, as well as the hows and whys, is distinctly weak and muddy. The film ends on a very Spielbergian note, which in itself may cause some viewers to groan in exasperation; it's made all the more frustrating given how poorly developed the alien's modus operandi and back story are. Ironically, one character utters a line that perfectly encapsulates the film's big, defining moment: "Wait.... what?"
Most of Super 8 works, but quite a bit of it feels undeniably shoehorned. Alien aside, the parents also could have used with a bit more fleshing out in the characterization department. Giacchino is definitely channeling his "Lost" sensibilities here for the soundtrack, and while the presentation is superb from a technical stance, it's not an especially memorable score. Those qualms aside, I liked what Abrams was going for overall. The film is a great homage to both the titular 8 mm format, and to visionary directors like Spielberg and George Lucas, who derived their movie-making passion from its use. To that end, what left me really liking the film was the far more satisfying resolution in store for those who are patient enough to sit through the credits. (Hint: You don't need to stay for the entire credit roll.)