Angela Jan 12, 2008
UPDATE TIME: Well, it seems I wasn't quick enough to cancel the TV Addicts order, since my account had been charged anyway. The upside, though, is that they actually SHIPPED the order, and it arrived today. I pretty much spent the day going through the set with a fine tooth comb.
I've kept my expectations low from the start, but it's actually pretty decent. The packaging looks exactly as it was advertised on the site. The DVDs are a no-name generic brand, and with the exception of some light smudges on discs three and four (which were easily wiped clean), I saw no physical problems with them.
I didn't bother so much with Season One as I did with Season Two, but all the episodes appear to be intact and completely watchable. The shows were, of course, recorded straight off television (the Women's Entertainment channel, in this case), so I did need to put up with the occasional "coming up next" ad that flashes on the bottom. Both discs are heavily compressed using mpeg-1, so the picture quality is about as well as to be expected from a disc boasting 12 twenty-two minute episodes each. (Think "EP" VCR quality.) The 2.1 sound channel is fine, and the editing is actually excellent; commercials were completely removed with proper fade-ins and outs. I did check out Season One's disc 1 and disc 2 briefly, just to see if they used the commercial DVD release. They didn't; it too was recorded off of TV.
Conclusion? I'm satisfied that I now have every episode of one of my most favorite TV shows, even if the visual quality is a few notches below average. Would I order from them again? Absolutely not. They're a shady company, no two ways about it, and based off the many cited horror stories, I consider myself lucky that I actually got what I ordered. I already took the proper precautions and steps to ensure that they don't charge my account again.