Ashley Winchester wrote:This may be a stupid question, and I'm not defending Dias (don't think he needs it), but why does his post create such a fervor and mine - which isn't really nice in tone either - doesn't?
I think the reason for that is that Idolores jumped at the opportunity of attacking Dais, while with you he has no quarrels. Idolores sentence "There we go. I've been waiting years to see you blow up over something small like that again." seems to suggest that he was just waiting for an excuse to fly off the handle and settle old scores with Dais (not surprising, as Dias has probably annoyed a gazillion people online by this time). You see this thing often on forums: someone suddenly jumping into a thread with a disproportionally acidic post that has less to do with the actual current discussion and more with an eruption of pent-up animosity. Drop it, Idolores.
I think this tangent between Idolores and Dias is unfortunate, as it obscured the more important point in the thread. I agree with Amazingu and Dias that Jodo probably has a lot of problems to take care of, and he never really answered their questions, instead avoiding them with more techno-babble. Jodo: just because one is "stable" doesn't mean that one is without problems. From your posts over the years, its easy to gather that you're not having an easy time relating to other human beings, and that you feel alone. Functioning perfectly at your workplace and in other such shallow, mostly anonymous social settings is possible for even the most detached, asocial individual, because in most such situations, you don't really need many human qualities to fulfill your task, you only need to be a cog in the system and perform your function while not making a fuss about it. What has bothered me most about your non-VGM-posts in the past is that you're trying to objectify everything. Like Dais pointed out, you're just putting on a cowardly front to avoid dealing with and cover up your deficiency in the emotional apartment. I'm not necessarily saying that you're not a logical person, people can be more or less logical, but if you're a human being, the logic, rational side is only one facet of the whole. The emotional, irrational-animal aspect is just as important to being a full human being, if you try to suppress that side because you have a hard time handling it and it disturbs you, you're just committing self-mutilation, lessening yourself. Personally, I used to have a similar idealistic view of becoming a "logical" creature. This was back in my foolish teenage years, when I hadn't really entered the irrational madhouse we know as "the adult world". We objectify things when we cannot deal with them, to have them under control, keep them at a "safe" and assuring distance. Religion came about as an objectification of myths concerning our origins, to keep primitive people in line and keep them working and obedient. When this crumbled in the Western world during the 19th century, what came about? Science, another (this time more accurate and less superstitious) way to objectify our surroundings, to explain the chaotic nature of existence to us in a believable manner and make it easier for us to deal with all the shit and sleep at night. And to relieve us from the bothersome hassle of actually having to look at the world and dealing with it.
Why do you listen to VGM, Jodo? Why do you watch movies? There is no purely logical reason for anyone to either do or not do these and all other things that we do to fill our time, because logic and rational reasoning can only show you the relation between different factors and premises, they can never in themselves tell you why you should do or not do something. The imperative drive in all living creatures is the irrational, unique emotion that wells up from within: logical calculations only follow afterward, as ad-hoc constructions. Logic is the means and the tool we use to attain our goals and satisfy our irrational longings, but logic can never give us the reason why we do this, can never give us our goals. After all, is there any logical reason for us to even be alive? Is there any logical reason for anything to exist rather than nothing at all?
I'm not trying to beat you up or make fun of you or anything like that. I think you're basically a good person, but you need to stop with all this childish posturing: its getting tiresome, dude. We see through it. Loosen up a bit, go out and get laid, and stop wasting your time on "gathering enough information" to understand a world that is ultimately more complex than any objectification can ever encompass. Chill.