This post is dedicated to my new thoughts on Inception. THERE ARE SPOILERS BELOW! I didn't want to white out the entire post, so I left it as is (it is on page 2 after all). PLEASE proceed with CAUTION if you fear SPOILERS!
Just got back from seeing it a second time and it held up really well. Knowing what goes down, the beginning felt a little slow, but things eventually picked up again and it was fun looking for "clues". Even with a second viewing there is still a lot to process. I haven't been able to reach a conclusion yet, but I did pick up on a few new things and I am leaning towards one particular theory. The theory is that Cobb has lost touch with reality and is in a dream the entire time. Some of the things I've seen that push me this direction are:
-Non-linearity: the film, like a dream, lacks a clearly defined beginning and end. It's a collection of segments that are loosely connected by Cobb's narrative. This is a weak argument, but I feel it is worth noticing. There were a variety of ways to organize and present the story and this particular decision warrants consideration. The story really does feel very surreal.
-The children: we never see Cobb's children in the "real world". Not until the very end that is. He has no photos, videos, mementos, nothing. We hear them once on the phone and that's it. It also bears mentioning that only Cobb experiences that phone conversation. No one else is present. When we do finally see the children at the end of the film, they look just like they always have; same age, same clothes, same activity, same everything. The only difference is that Cobb accepts them this time. Nothing else has really changed.
-Cobb's delusions: when dreaming, aspects of Cobb's life pop up repeatedly; Mal, the kids, the train, the broken glass, the balcony, etc. Some of these things creep briefly into the "real world" though. Granted, they aren't exactly the same as in the dreams, but there are a couple instances when Cobb thinks he sees them in the real world. Perhaps he's just a little unstable, or maybe things aren't entirely the way the seem.
-Real world projections: as Mal observes in Limbo, Cobb is always being pursued in the "real world". There's the police in the US, enemies Cobb has made while doing jobs, angry employers, etc. All the main characters in the film also offer some sort of insight to Cobb (especially Ariadne). Some characters even have very specific lines that seem to question reality and Cobb's perceptions of it. In fact, the only character that seems positive he knows what's real and what isn't is Cobb. Everyone has their doubts from time to time except him. He's obsessed with his totem and the "real world".
-Cobb's totem: and that brings us here. Cobb's totem isn't his totem at all. It was Mal's. She conceived it, she shared it with him, and it seems that he may have in fact gotten his exact model from her. Doesn't sound like a very effective totem does it? This particular totem is also used as the symbol for the secret that Mal hid away and the Cobb tampered with. There's something more going on with this totem than meets the eye. There's the scene where he drops it and Saito also gets to hold it towards the end of the film. If nothing else, I think it's safe to assume that this totem is corrupted and not nearly as reliable as we, and Cobb, believe.
The story really seems to be exclusively about Cobb. It's about his unresolved conflict (guilt) with Mal and his perception (acceptance?) of reality. Both of these issues are present at the film's start and both are resolved by the end: Cobb has dealt with Mal and has accepted the world that he's in (real or not). Whether or not the top stops is immaterial because Cobb doesn't care and thus we, as the audience observing his journey, don't really need to know. Add to that the fact that the totem may not even be reliable in the first place and the issue isn't really an issue at all.
Seeing the film a second time and thinking about it has changed my perceptions a little bit. The first time I was really hung up on the end: what happened? Was Cobb really home? This time around that didn't feel so important. Cobb stopped caring and accepted where he was. That rubbed off on me and, instead of trying to unravel the ending, I was more interested in trying to get inside Cobb's mind. We spend a lot of time there (perhaps even the whole time) and so it seems pertinent. That's when I started noticing some of the character interactions. I'm having a hard time remembering specific lines, but there were several that just felt out of place. The majority of them came from Ariadne and Miles (grandpa). They feel so much more like projections than independent entities.
I don't know. It's so easy to read too much into a film like this one. I kind of like that though. As for the ending... although I didn't focus on it this time around, it still felt fake. Everything was just too perfect. Everyone was there, it looked the same as in Cobb's memories, the children hadn't changed, Miles (grandpa) was there waiting, grandma was nowhere to be seen... it's just too neat a package for me to accept. Everything else in the film was so complicated and gray. I find it hard to believe that every single conflict could be resolved with a single phone call. It feels more like a mental success for Cobb. He's worked through his conflicts and reached closure. Reality? Maybe, maybe not. He's obtained his goal though and his journey is complete.
Any new thoughts from you guys? Notice anything new on a second viewing? I think it's time for me to start seeing what the internet has to say. :3